Groups Seek Stricter Federal Nitrate Limits in Drinking Water
A petition calls for lowering the federal nitrate limit by 90%, citing health research and widespread contamination.
A coalition of 16 environmental and public health organizations is calling on the Environmental Protection Agency to lower the federal drinking water standard for nitrate by 90%, citing research linking contamination to increased risks of cancer, adverse birth outcomes and other health concerns.
The organizations submitted a petition to the EPA on Nov. 16 requesting that the agency reduce the maximum contaminant level for nitrate from 10 milligrams per liter to 1 milligram per liter. The groups also want the EPA to establish an interim standard while it considers a permanent revision.
The petitioners include Food & Water Watch, the Natural Resources Defense Council, Environmental Working Group, Union of Concerned Scientists and Alliance for the Great Lakes.
The current federal nitrate limit was established in 1975 and has remained unchanged. According to the coalition, subsequent research has identified potential health risks associated with nitrate concentrations below the existing regulatory threshold.
Nitrate contamination is commonly associated with agricultural fertilizer runoff and animal manure, although wastewater discharges and septic systems can also contribute to elevated concentrations in surface water and groundwater.
Nearly 120 Million People Served by Affected Water Systems
The petition includes an analysis identifying 13,205 community water systems serving approximately 119.7 million people that recorded at least one nitrate measurement at or above 1 mg/L between 2021 and 2023.
The figure represents the population served by systems with recorded concentrations at or above the proposed threshold, not necessarily the number of people continuously exposed to those concentrations.
The coalition argues that existing regulations do not adequately account for research associating nitrate exposure with colorectal cancer, thyroid disease and adverse pregnancy outcomes.
In a statement announcing the petition, Stacy Woods, research director at the Union of Concerned Scientists, said research conducted since the current standard was established has identified additional health concerns.
The petition also asks the EPA to establish a maximum contaminant level goal of zero for nitrate. Unlike the enforceable maximum contaminant level, the goal represents a health-based target rather than a regulatory compliance requirement.
Potential Implications for Water Utilities
Lowering the federal nitrate standard could require drinking water utilities to increase monitoring, install additional treatment equipment or modify existing treatment processes.
The petition identifies ion exchange, reverse osmosis and biological denitrification among the technologies available to reduce nitrate concentrations.
An economic analysis included with the filing estimates that a 1 mg/L standard could generate approximately $364.1 billion in public health benefits over a 50-year period, compared with $94.5 billion in compliance costs under a modeled least-cost treatment scenario.
The estimates cover 2027 through 2076 and are expressed in 2026 dollars, using a 2% discount rate. They are projections prepared for the petitioners and depend on assumptions about health outcomes, treatment technologies and compliance costs.
The organizations acknowledge that additional treatment requirements could create financial challenges for smaller and rural drinking water systems.
They are asking the EPA to use existing federal grant and loan programs to help utilities finance treatment improvements and source water protection measures.
Addressing Pollution at the Source
Beyond revising the drinking water standard, the coalition is urging the EPA to strengthen efforts to reduce nitrate contamination before it reaches public water supplies.
The petition identifies agricultural runoff, including fertilizer applications and manure from livestock operations, as major contributors to nitrate pollution.
The groups argue that reducing contamination at its source could lower treatment costs for drinking water providers and provide additional benefits for communities relying on private wells.
Angela Blatt, senior agriculture policy manager at the Alliance for the Great Lakes, said stronger drinking water standards should be accompanied by measures to prevent pollution from entering water supplies.
“Treatment alone cannot be the answer,” Blatt said in the coalition’s announcement.
The petition also calls for greater federal assistance to communities facing persistent nitrate contamination, particularly those with limited financial resources.
Federal Review Requested
Under the Safe Drinking Water Act, the EPA periodically reviews national drinking water regulations to determine whether revisions are appropriate.
The coalition argues that the current nitrate standard does not reflect more recent research on potential long-term health effects.
The organizations are requesting both an immediate interim limit of 1 mg/L and a permanent revision of the federal standard.
The filing does not change existing drinking water requirements, and the EPA has not announced a proposed rule in response.
Any revision to the enforceable federal limit would require further regulatory action.
The petition adds to ongoing discussions about agricultural pollution, drinking water treatment costs and the role of federal standards in protecting public water supplies.