Heisman of Week 11: Duke’s Nate Sheppard has entered the running
Sports 12 min read

Heisman of Week 11: Duke’s Nate Sheppard has entered the running

By November 17, 2026


Can we talk for a moment about how awesome and unexpected the running back position currently is in college football?

The top five backs in terms of yards per game from scrimmage — probably the best way to measure an running back’s success in the current game — are, in order, Duke’s Nate Sheppard, Oklahoma State’s Caleb Hawkins, North Texas’ Jahiem White, Boise State’s Dylan Riley and Iowa State’s Aiden Flora. They range delightfully in size and shape, from the 5-foot-7, 190-pound White to the 6-foot, 219-pound Hawkins, but they are all, to the naked eye, dynamite: explosive in the open field and, in some cases, stronger and sturdier than they look. (Granted, Hawkins in particular looks pretty strong and sturdy.)

Only one of the five was truly unheralded — Flora was a walk-on from Adel, Iowa, population 6,153 — but the other four were mid-three-star prospects choosing relatively midtier schools. (Hawkins started at North Texas, White at West Virginia.) But in a rather small amount of time, they have become the best players at their position. Sheppard and Hawkins are each in only their second years of college but have already combined for 6,589 yards from scrimmage and 74 touchdowns in 47 games. Flora quickly played as a walk-on true freshman and has enjoyed a star turn in Year 3. Riley was one of Ashton Jeanty’s reserves as a true freshman in 2024 and has gained 2,793 yards from scrimmage with 25 TDs in the 24 games since.

Combine that with 2025 stars such as Missouri’s Ahmad Hardy (who started at Louisiana-Monroe the year before and was an immediate star), Ole Miss’ Kewan Lacy (a mid-three-star recruit and second-year star) and Nebraska’s Emmett Johnson (maybe the lowest-rated member of Nebraska’s 2022 recruiting class), and the running back position is becoming a sort of fairy tale. Anyone your team signs could be the next Hardy or Hawkins, and any school could turn out to have the best back in the country.

Though Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith made his reemergence in the Heisman race this past weekend, and though the rest of the current favorites list is made up of quarterbacks from awesome teams, as is customary, two of these running backs stole the show in Week 11.

Sheppard accounted for about two-thirds of Duke’s yards as the Blue Devils tried (and eventually failed) to put together an upset bid against No. 7 Miami, and Flora was both consistent and explosive against Cincinnati. They are two of only six players to have appeared on this Heisman of the Week list four times — the others are Smith, Alabama’s Keelon Russell, Miami’s Darian Mensah and Mississippi State’s Kamario Taylor — and no one has done so more.

This season, Heisman is running its Heisman Hopefuls Fan Vote all season long, with a platform that provides statistics, EA Sports ratings and other information. In that vein, I am once again awarding the Heisman every week of the season and doling out weekly points, F1-style (10 points for first place, nine for second and so on). But because of injuries and midseason plot twists, I elected to start doubling the points in November — now first place is worth 20, second 18, and on and on. Predictably, the points race has taken on some interesting twists because of it.

This week’s Heisman winner: Nate Sheppard

1. Nate Sheppard, Duke

Week 11 numbers: 16 carries for 141 yards and two TDs, plus 93 receiving yards against Miami

Sheppard showed off his entire skill set against Miami on Saturday. He is certainly as fast and strong as one would expect of the nation’s best back, but his vision and split-second decision-making make him even faster on the field. Because college football is basically European soccer in the way the Transfer Industrial Complex is taking over the sport, I know this is where I’m supposed to immediately start speculating about where Sheppard is going to be playing his third year of college ball next year. But I hate all that, so I’m just going to say that Manny Diaz and his staff did a hell of an eval job here, and I love that Duke has the best back in the sport.


The rest of the top 10

2. Aiden Flora, Iowa State

Week 11 numbers: 28 carries for 216 yards and three TDs, plus 38 receiving yards against Cincinnati

Early in the season, Flora was basically torching lesser defenses (14 touches, 204 yards against Bowling Green) while predictably struggling against better ones (94.7 yards per game from scrimmage and 5.0 per touch against Utah, Iowa and BYU). Now he’s just torching any defense that shows up in front of him. He has gained 677 yards from scrimmage with six touchdowns in his past three weeks, a run that includes a bout with a tough Baylor defense. Flora is ISU’s everything: The Cyclones are 4-1 when he tops 200 yards from scrimmage and 1-4 when he doesn’t.

3. Jelani McDonald, Texas

Week 11 numbers: 11 tackles, three interceptions and a pass breakup against LSU

Texas is almost home free in the race to secure a College Football Playoff bid, and though the offense provided late heroics in scoring the winning touchdown with three seconds left, it was the Longhorns’ defense, as always, that carried most of the weight. McDonald, a second-year starter and former blue-chipper, was Saturday’s standout, not only recording a hat trick of interceptions but grabbing two of them in the Texas end zone. He prevented almost as many points as LSU’s offense scored.

4. Rasean Jones, Boise State

Week 11 numbers: 11 catches for 230 yards and three TDs, plus a game-clinching 9-yard run against Oregon State

Somehow Jesse Legree wasn’t the best freshman receiver on the field in Saturday’s BSU-OSU track meet. Jones stole the show, catching 11 of 12 balls, including five on third down and this absolute masterpiece on fourth-and-2.

When it was time to ice the game on third-and-7 with 1:52 left, BSU did the only sensible thing: give the ball to Jones on a jet sweep. He gained nine. It was an unreal game from a burgeoning star: Jones has 27 touches for 472 yards and seven touchdowns in his past three games.

5. Devon Dampier, Utah

Week 11 numbers: 13-for-25 passing for 204 yards, two TDs and one INT, plus 106 non-sack rushing yards and two TDs against Arizona

Dampier’s reliability has almost gotten him lost in the shuffle in this Heisman points race. Utah has won enough blowouts that he’s averaging only 32.2 dropbacks per game, and he hasn’t gone over 280 passing yards in any single contest. And though he can run, he typically does so only in closer games. But in Utah’s three biggest wins (against BYU, Houston and Arizona), he averaged 14.7 non-sack carries, 119.0 yards and 2.0 touchdowns while also averaging an efficient 7.6 yards per dropback. He does what’s required, and when a huge pass was required late Saturday night in Tucson, he delivered.

6. Darian Mensah, Miami

Week 11 numbers: 30-for-41 passing for 382 yards and a touchdown against Duke

Speaking of contenders who get overshadowed, Mensah didn’t earn as many horse race points as he could have early in the season because I was giving them to star receiver Malachi Toney instead, and when he has a great game in a win over Duke, I end up giving more points and words to the vanquished Sheppard. Regardless, Mensah is awesome, and pretty well positioned in the overall points race.

7. Daniel Bray, Utah

Week 11 numbers: 18 carries for 197 yards and a touchdown, plus 21 receiving yards against Arizona

Utah needed not only Dampier but also a career game from Bray to get past Arizona on Saturday night. Starting running back Wayshawn Parker was out, but you couldn’t tell it because of bursts of 62, 33, 19 and 15 yards from the sophomore from Fort Worth.

8. Jeremiah Smith, Ohio State

Week 11 numbers: 11 catches for 117 yards and touchdowns against Northwestern

As I wrote in Sunday’s Week 11 recap, “It’s a reflection of how much the quarterback position hogs the oxygen that Smith’s candidacy fell apart in part because Ohio State signal-caller Julian Sayin got hurt and was replaced by freshman Luke Fahey. If we’re somehow judging Smith for that, it’s perhaps OK to give him double credit for Saturday’s performance. He was good.”

9. Maddux Madsen, Boise State

Week 11 numbers: 23-for-32 passing for 371 yards and four TDs, plus 25 non-rushing yards against Oregon State

Even after adjusting for opponents, Madsen currently ranks second nationally in Total QBR. His completion rate ranks 26th (67.3%), and his explosiveness perked up against Oregon State (in part because of Jones), but his superpower is an almost total lack of mistakes: He has thrown one interception and taken only seven sacks. That old “only three things can happen when you pass, and two of them are bad” quote, historically attributed to about three different cranky old coaches, doesn’t apply when Madsen is looking to throw.

10. Myles Bradley, Bowling Green

Week 11 numbers: nine tackles, five sacks, a run stop, a forced fumble and a pass breakup against Kent State

Only two defenders have shown up on this list multiple times in 2026 (which might be a signal that I need to do a better job of celebrating awesome defenders). The first was Texas’ Colin Simmons, who might have been on his way to a genuine Heisman push before sitting out most of three games because of injury. The second is Bradley, a BGSU lifer who has erupted in his fifth and final season. His 14 sacks comfortably lead the nation (no one else has more than 11.5), and BGSU needed every one of his five last week to secure a 33-28 win.

Honorable mention:

• Joel Boamah, Missouri State (four tackles, a forced fumble, a fumble recovery and a winning overtime pick-six against New Mexico State).

• Messiah Burch, Buffalo (31 carries for 209 yards and two TDs against Ball State).

• Brad Jackson, Texas State (25-for-33 passing for 355 yards and three TDs, plus 63 non-sack rushing yards against Fresno State).

• Joker Johnson, Arkansas (seven tackles, a forced fumble and two interceptions, including a pick-six, against South Carolina).

• Gio Lopez, Wake Forest (14-for-25 passing for 201 yards and a touchdown, plus 42 non-sack rushing yards and two scores against SMU).

• Aidan Mizell, UCLA (six catches for 176 yards and a touchdown against Illinois).

• Qua Russaw, Ohio State (five tackles, three TFLs, one sack and two run stops against Northwestern).

• Gunner Stockton, Georgia (18-for-24 passing for 252 yards and a touchdown, plus a rushing touchdown against Missouri).

• Marcus Stokes, Memphis (15-for-31 passing for 313 yards and three TDs, plus 78 non-sack rushing yards and two TDs against South Florida).

• Cole Tabb, Cincinnati (16 carries for 165 yards, plus 70 receiving yards against Iowa State).


Point totals and current odds

Through 11 weeks, here are your points leaders. As always, players who are also in the top 10 in the DraftKings Heisman betting odds are in bold. (In the event of a tie, I use a player’s points in the past four weeks as the first tiebreaker.)

1. Nate Sheppard, Duke (43 points)

2. Aiden Flora, Iowa State (34 points)

3. Jeremiah Smith, Ohio State (33.5 points)

4. Michael Hawkins Jr., West Virginia (29 points, 12 in the past four weeks)

5. Keelon Russell, Alabama (29 points, 4 in the past four weeks)

6. Darian Mensah, Miami (27 points, 23 in the past four weeks)

7. Malachi Toney, Miami (27 points, 9 in the past four weeks)

8. Caleb Hawkins, Oklahoma (25 points)

9. CJ Carr, Notre Dame (22 points, 20 in the past four weeks)

10. Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss (22 points, 7 in the past four weeks)

Though Georgia’s Gunner Stockton (nine points in the horse race, fifth in betting odds) might technically still have a chance, the betting odds suggest we’re basically down to four contenders: Smith, Mensah, Dampier and Carr. Then again, the odds looked almost completely different last week, with Carr favored and Smith falling behind. We definitely still have time for a few more vibe shifts, and maybe in one of those shifts, voters will notice Sheppard or another ridiculous running back. At this point, at least, Sheppard has my vote.


Gordie Lockbaum of the week: Jase Ferguson, Clarion

Week 11 numbers: 18-for-32 passing for 310 yards, four TDs and one INT, plus 99 rushing yards, a touchdown as part of a 28-point fourth-quarter comeback against Millersville

There were, as always, plenty of incredible performances at the smaller-school level, from St. Thomas’ Joseph Koch rushing for 233 yards and five TDs against Drake, to Yale’s Abu Kamara making four TFLs with a big interception return against Princeton, to Illinois State’s Seth Glatz posting 201 yards from scrimmage in a vital win over Youngstown State, to huge Division II performances such as those of Minnesota Moorhead’s Drew Huebner (413 passing yards against No. 10 Minnesota State) and CSU Pueblo’s Navi Bruzon (326 passing yards and 43 rushing yards against No. 4 Western Colorado).

But this week’s Lockbaum goes to Ferguson because holy cow. Clarion found itself trailing 1-10 Millersville by a shocking 42-14 margin early in the fourth quarter, but after Tyreeck Hall kick-started the comeback with a kick-return TD, Ferguson took it from there. He made it 42-28 with a 26-yard TD run with 5:29 left, and after an onside kick recovery, he threw a 17-yard TD to Davon Jones. Millersville recovered the next onside kick but failed on fourth-and-short with 1:03 left, and Ferguson threw another TD pass to Jones, then scored the winning 2-pointer with his legs. The redshirt freshman finished with 409 total yards, five total TDs and a Senior Day comeback for the ages.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *