Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Facebook Reading Android Photo Galleries Without Consent
International Business 6 min read

Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Facebook Reading Android Photo Galleries Without Consent

By November 17, 2026

Your phone’s photo gallery is private. Italy’s privacy regulator has now put a price on a company treating it as anything else — €805 million.

By Tariq Jamal
Freelance Journalist | The BNN Media – The Best News Network
News Beyond the Borders

ROME, Italy — Italy’s data protection authority, the Garante, has fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited €805 million — about $887 million (£670 million) — after finding that the Facebook app for Android accessed photos, videos and metadata stored in users’ phone galleries without specific consent and without properly informing them, in a decision issued on Saturday, 14 November.

Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Facebook Reading Android Photo Galleries Without Consent
Meta chief executive Mark Zuckerberg. (File photo from the F8 developers’ conference in 2019 — not from the Italian proceedings.)

A Fine Among the Largest Ever

The penalty is among the largest fines an Italian authority has ever imposed on a technology company, according to the BBC, and the largest the Garante itself has ever handed down. The authority put the fine at about 0.47% of Meta’s worldwide turnover — a figure that underlines both the scale of the company and the seriousness with which the regulator views the breach.

The decision targets a single feature, but one that touches the daily life of millions of people. The Garante counted roughly 20 million Android users in Italy as affected — effectively, a large share of everyone in the country who uses Facebook on an Android phone.

For a regulator, the message is the size of the number. For Meta, the number is small change — 0.47% of turnover. The argument now is about which of those two readings the rest of Europe accepts.

How the Feature Worked

The feature at the centre of the case has been available since 2023. In Italian it is called “Ottieni suggerimenti dalla galleria quando navighi su Facebook” — “Get suggestions from your gallery while browsing Facebook”. As a user scrolls through the app, it suggests photos and videos from the phone’s own gallery as ideas for posts.

The Garante’s technical analysis found four things wrong with how that worked. Access to the gallery was requested through a single permission that covered the whole app and several functions with different purposes. The request came after a generic notice — about enabling “other features” — that did not say gallery suggestions were part of it. The feature was switched on by default. And once the permission was fully granted, the app could read the entire photo archive, generally on an ongoing basis, in a way that neither the user nor the regulator could check in detail.

Meta's headquarters campus in Menlo Park, California
Meta’s headquarters campus in Menlo Park, California. (File photo)

Why Consent Failed

The legal ground is Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which implements the European Union’s ePrivacy Directive. Under that rule, the Garante treats a smartphone as part of a person’s private sphere — so any access to information stored on it requires free and informed consent, whether or not the data leaves the device and whether or not anyone is harmed.

The Garante’s position is that a device permission was only the starting point. A bundled grant, a vague notice and a default-on setting did not add up to valid consent, because consent to handle personal material has to be specific and explicit — separate for each purpose, with the user told plainly what the data will be used for.

Meta’s position, as reported in coverage of the decision, is that the feature only works after users grant device permission, and that users can change that permission at any time. The regulator took a different view: the permission users gave was for the app as a whole, not for the gallery suggestions feature in particular.

The investigation began in July 2025, after a report from the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti di Bolzano, the consumer protection centre in Bolzano, which had published an advisory about the feature and asked the Garante to investigate. The regulator then ran its own technical analysis, and the proceedings ran for about 16 months before the decision.

What Meta Must Do Now

The fine is only part of the order. Within 60 days, Meta must switch the feature off by default and ask Italian users for separate, specific consent before the app can reach their galleries — including users who had already granted the system permission. It must also tell users plainly what the data will be used for and how to switch the feature off, and it must report on the measures adopted within 90 days.

Meta has said it will appeal and has called the penalty “disproportionate”. The company has the right to challenge the decision, and any appeal will test whether the Garante’s reading of consent — specific, explicit, and separate for each purpose — survives in court.

The case also matters beyond Italy because of the legal route the Garante used. By acting under the ePrivacy rules in Italy’s own Privacy Code, rather than routing the case through Ireland, where Meta has its European base, the authority showed that other European regulators could bring similar cases of their own. Europe accounts for about 23% of Meta’s revenue, so the precedent is worth far more than the fine itself.

The AI Question Left Open

One question the decision deliberately does not answer is whether material from users’ galleries was used to train artificial intelligence models. That issue was not examined in this case, and Meta denies that gallery content was used for AI training. A separate, newer feature launched in 2026, which allows cloud processing of gallery content, may be assessed separately by the Garante.

That matters because it is the question many users will ask first. The fine is about access and consent, not about what Meta did with the photos afterwards — and on that second question, the regulator has reserved its position.

A person using a smartphone
A person using a smartphone. The fine concerns the Facebook app for Android, which the Garante says reached into users’ photo galleries without specific consent. (File photo)

What Happens Next

  • The fine: €805 million (about $887 million / £670 million), about 0.47% of Meta’s worldwide turnover.
  • Who was affected: about 20 million Android users in Italy; the feature has run since 2023.
  • The deadline: within 60 days, Meta must switch the feature off by default and seek separate, specific consent; it must report on the measures adopted within 90 days.
  • The appeal: Meta calls the fine “disproportionate” and says it will appeal.
  • Still open: whether gallery material was used to train AI (not covered by this decision; Meta denies it), and a separate assessment of the 2026 cloud-processing feature.

For the millions of Italians whose photo galleries were within the app’s reach, the decision changes something practical within two months: a feature that was on unless they found the switch will be off unless they actively choose it. For the rest of Europe’s regulators, the decision is a template — and for Meta, the €805 million is the cost of the first test of it.

A phone’s photo gallery holds a person’s life. Italy has now ruled that reaching into it is not a detail buried in an app permission — it is a decision that needs a person’s clear, specific yes.

By Tariq Jamal
Freelance Journalist | The BNN Media – The Best News Network
News Beyond the Borders

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *